{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "rule_version": "data-quality-review-map/1.0.0", "snapshot_date": "2026-08-12", "status": { "gate_version": "1.0.0", "assertion_kind": "data_quality_review_map", "public_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "claim_level": "candidate", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "missing_requirements": [ "primary_text", "edition", "rights", "human_review" ], "allowed_claims": [ "review_candidate" ], "prohibited_claims": [ "direct", "verified", "efficacy", "historical_lineage" ], "source_state": { "snapshot_date": "2026-08-12", "rule_version": "data-quality-review-map/1.0.0", "correction_history_updated_at": "2026-08-14" } }, "scope": { "source": "KTKP public-source records", "formulas": 20120, "herbs": 5500, "diseases": 12500, "total_records": 38120 }, "interpretation": { "no_combined_total": true, "warning": "네 레인은 세는 단위가 달라 합산하지 않습니다. 자동 후보는 오류 확정, 동일 개념, 단위 환산, 임상효능 또는 역사적 계보를 뜻하지 않습니다.", "prohibited_automatic_actions": [ "fill_blank", "merge_records", "convert_units", "complete_relation", "promote_to_verified" ] }, "assertion_states": { "review_candidate_unreviewed": { "confirmed_error": false, "meaning": "자동 규칙이 다시 확인할 지점을 찾았지만 사람이 근거를 대조하지 않은 상태", "required_evidence": [ "primary_text_or_official_record", "edition_or_source_identity", "reuse_rights", "human_review" ] }, "confirmed_error": { "confirmed_error": true, "meaning": "공식 원천 또는 판본 위치와 사람 검토로 오류를 확인해 공개 이력에 연결한 상태", "required_evidence": [ "record_id", "field", "official_url_or_edition_locator", "human_review", "correction_history_entry" ] } }, "assertion_summary": { "review_candidate_lane_count": 4, "representative_candidate_count": 27, "confirmed_error_count": 0 }, "lanes": [ { "id": "unresolved_core_blank", "label": "미해결 핵심값 공란", "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "count_basis": "records", "candidate_count": 1, "review_queue": { "rank": 1, "label": "핵심 표시값 확인", "rationale": "기록을 식별하는 화면 핵심값이 비어 있어 먼저 원자료를 확인합니다." }, "rule": "공개 후보 대장에서 화면용 값으로도 복구하지 못한 핵심 공란만 셉니다.", "caveat": "공란은 자동으로 채우지 않으며, 원자료 오류로 확정하지 않습니다.", "examples": [ { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:unresolved-source-blank:formula:P0016491:hanja", "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0016491", "name": "양로탕", "source_marker": "", "field": "hanja", "display_policy": "do_not_infer", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0016491" } ] }, { "id": "same_name_hanja_group", "label": "화면에서 이름·한자가 같은 기록군", "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "count_basis": "groups", "candidate_count": 4550, "record_count": 15189, "review_queue": { "rank": 3, "label": "기록 병합 전 구분 확인", "rationale": "이름과 한자가 같아도 별도 기록일 수 있으므로 합치기 전에 확인합니다." }, "subcounts": { "formula": { "group_count": 3542, "record_count": 12341 }, "herb": { "group_count": 985, "record_count": 2802 }, "disease": { "group_count": 23, "record_count": 46 } }, "rule": "지도와 기록 페이지에서 보이는 이름·한자를 같은 형식으로 맞춘 뒤, 같은 자료 유형 안에 똑같은 표시가 2개 이상인 기록군을 셉니다.", "caveat": "같은 표기는 중복·오류·동일 개념을 뜻하지 않습니다. 자동 병합하지 않습니다.", "examples": [ { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:formula:669e939498ffb65b", "type": "formula", "name": "가감계지탕", "hanja": "加減桂枝湯", "source_markers": [ "A", "B" ], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "P0000002", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000002" }, { "source_id": "P0008499", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0008499" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:formula:9701f50daf94691e", "type": "formula", "name": "가감고본환", "hanja": "加減固本丸", "source_markers": [ "A", "B" ], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "P0000003", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000003" }, { "source_id": "P0004755", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0004755" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:formula:f915a7a1b7572428", "type": "formula", "name": "가감금궤신기환", "hanja": "加減金匱腎氣丸", "source_markers": [ "A", "B" ], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "P0015600", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0015600" }, { "source_id": "P0015601", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0015601" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:formula:5aa64863a1702ead", "type": "formula", "name": "가감내고환", "hanja": "加減內固丸", "source_markers": [ "A", "B", "C" ], "member_count": 3, "members": [ { "source_id": "P0000005", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000005" }, { "source_id": "P0004756", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0004756" }, { "source_id": "P0013562", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0013562" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:herb:0dd60935162a23b7", "type": "herb", "name": "가자", "hanja": "訶子", "source_markers": [ "A", "B" ], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "M0000008", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000008" }, { "source_id": "M0000009", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000009" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:herb:0b645298f1f9bce0", "type": "herb", "name": "가자피", "hanja": "訶子皮", "source_markers": [ "A", "B" ], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "M0000011", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000011" }, { "source_id": "M0000012", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000012" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:herb:fb76189e7989fdcd", "type": "herb", "name": "각향", "hanja": "角香", "source_markers": [ "A", "B", "C" ], "member_count": 3, "members": [ { "source_id": "M0000020", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000020" }, { "source_id": "M0000021", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000021" }, { "source_id": "M0000022", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000022" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:herb:1f61974145635e58", "type": "herb", "name": "각호", "hanja": "角蒿", "source_markers": [ "A", "B", "C", "D" ], "member_count": 4, "members": [ { "source_id": "M0000023", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000023" }, { "source_id": "M0000024", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000024" }, { "source_id": "M0000025", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000025" }, { "source_id": "M0000026", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000026" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:disease:d213a439fbfb9aa3", "type": "disease", "name": "귀흉", "hanja": "龜胸", "source_markers": [], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "D0001134", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001134" }, { "source_id": "D0012697", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0012697" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:disease:47ded5c88f291ea8", "type": "disease", "name": "금은동석철독", "hanja": "金銀銅錫鐵毒", "source_markers": [], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "D0001227", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001227" }, { "source_id": "D0001447", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001447" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:disease:9fd281c339f425eb", "type": "disease", "name": "금창", "hanja": "金瘡", "source_markers": [], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "D0001231", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001231" }, { "source_id": "D0001450", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001450" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:same-display-label:disease:0db9b25bbc70bf0b", "type": "disease", "name": "금창출혈", "hanja": "金瘡出血", "source_markers": [], "member_count": 2, "members": [ { "source_id": "D0001239", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001239" }, { "source_id": "D0001452", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001452" } ] } ] }, { "id": "mixed_recorded_units", "label": "한 처방 안의 단위 혼재", "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "count_basis": "formula_records", "candidate_count": 2, "review_queue": { "rank": 2, "label": "분량 계산 전 단위 확인", "rationale": "한 처방 안의 단위가 섞여 있어 어떤 자동 환산도 하기 전에 확인합니다." }, "rule": "모든 구성 항목에서 양수와 g·mg·kg 중 한 단위를 읽을 수 있지만, 한 처방 안에 둘 이상의 단위가 있을 때만 셉니다.", "caveat": "단위를 자동 환산하거나 치료 용량으로 해석하지 않습니다.", "examples": [ { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:mixed-recorded-units:formula:P0005522", "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0005522", "name": "밀지전", "hanja": "蜜脂煎", "source_marker": "B", "recorded_units": [ "g", "kg" ], "ingredient_count": 2, "record_path": "/records/formula/P0005522" }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:mixed-recorded-units:formula:P0006805", "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0006805", "name": "천진환", "hanja": "天眞丸", "source_marker": "A", "recorded_units": [ "g", "kg" ], "ingredient_count": 5, "record_path": "/records/formula/P0006805" } ] }, { "id": "one_sided_public_relation", "label": "한쪽 공개목록에만 적힌 연결", "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "count_basis": "deduplicated_relations", "candidate_count": 142439, "review_queue": { "rank": 4, "label": "관계 해석 전 목록 확인", "rationale": "한쪽 목록에만 적힌 이유를 확인하되 상대 목록을 자동 보충하지 않습니다." }, "subcounts": { "fh": { "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "herb" ], "first_declares_second": 125592, "second_declares_first": 42, "total": 125634 }, "fd": { "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "disease" ], "first_declares_second": 15735, "second_declares_first": 583, "total": 16318 }, "hd": { "endpoint_types": [ "herb", "disease" ], "first_declares_second": 23, "second_declares_first": 464, "total": 487 } }, "rule": "두 공개기록의 명칭을 보수적으로 연결한 뒤, 한쪽 기록의 관계 목록에만 이름이 적힌 중복 제거 연결을 셉니다.", "caveat": "목록의 비대칭은 원자료 오류나 의학적 관계의 부재를 뜻하지 않습니다. 양쪽 목록을 자동 보충하지 않습니다.", "examples": [ { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fd:P0000003:D0009135", "kind": "fd", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "disease" ], "declared_by": "formula", "not_declared_by": "disease", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000003", "name": "가감고본환", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000003" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0009135", "name": "졸중", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0009135" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fd:P0000003:D0011920", "kind": "fd", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "disease" ], "declared_by": "formula", "not_declared_by": "disease", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000003", "name": "가감고본환", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000003" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0011920", "name": "희망", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0011920" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fd:P0000002:D0007181", "kind": "fd", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "disease" ], "declared_by": "disease", "not_declared_by": "formula", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000002", "name": "가감계지탕", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000002" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0007181", "name": "오풍", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0007181" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fd:P0000131:D0004833", "kind": "fd", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "disease" ], "declared_by": "disease", "not_declared_by": "formula", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000131", "name": "가미통심음", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000131" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0004833", "name": "소변불통", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0004833" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fh:P0000023:M0000073", "kind": "fh", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "herb" ], "declared_by": "formula", "not_declared_by": "herb", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000023", "name": "가감삼기탕", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000023" }, { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0000073", "name": "감초", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000073" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fh:P0000024:M0000073", "kind": "fh", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "herb" ], "declared_by": "formula", "not_declared_by": "herb", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000024", "name": "가감삼요탕", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000024" }, { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0000073", "name": "감초", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000073" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fh:P0000057:M0004191", "kind": "fh", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "herb" ], "declared_by": "herb", "not_declared_by": "formula", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000057", "name": "가감유령탕", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000057" }, { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0004191", "name": "향유", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0004191" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:fh:P0000154:M0004191", "kind": "fh", "endpoint_types": [ "formula", "herb" ], "declared_by": "herb", "not_declared_by": "formula", "endpoints": [ { "type": "formula", "source_id": "P0000154", "name": "갈묘고", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/formula/P0000154" }, { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0004191", "name": "향유", "source_marker": "A", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0004191" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:hd:M0001622:D0008298", "kind": "hd", "endpoint_types": [ "herb", "disease" ], "declared_by": "herb", "not_declared_by": "disease", "endpoints": [ { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0001622", "name": "불회목", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0001622" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0008298", "name": "인후종통", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0008298" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:hd:M0001622:D0010426", "kind": "hd", "endpoint_types": [ "herb", "disease" ], "declared_by": "herb", "not_declared_by": "disease", "endpoints": [ { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0001622", "name": "불회목", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0001622" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0010426", "name": "폐열해수", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0010426" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:hd:M0000001:D0004832", "kind": "hd", "endpoint_types": [ "herb", "disease" ], "declared_by": "disease", "not_declared_by": "herb", "endpoints": [ { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0000001", "name": "가도", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000001" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0004832", "name": "소변불리", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0004832" } ] }, { "assertion_status": "review_candidate_unreviewed", "review_status": "unreviewed", "promotion_status": "locked", "assertion_id": "dq-v1:one-sided-public-relation:hd:M0000017:D0001231", "kind": "hd", "endpoint_types": [ "herb", "disease" ], "declared_by": "disease", "not_declared_by": "herb", "endpoints": [ { "type": "herb", "source_id": "M0000017", "name": "가화", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/herb/M0000017" }, { "type": "disease", "source_id": "D0001231", "name": "금창", "source_marker": "", "record_path": "/records/disease/D0001231" } ] } ] } ], "confirmed_errors": [], "correction_history": { "path": "/atlas/data/public/correction-history.json", "updated_at": "2026-08-14", "entry_count": 9, "status_counts": { "received": 0, "needs_evidence": 1, "verified_open": 0, "resolved": 8, "upstream_only": 0 }, "candidate_specific_review_events": 1, "linked_assertion_ids": 4, "reviewed_candidates": 0, "confirmed_candidates": 0, "resolved_candidates": 0, "note": "기존 정정 이력은 프로젝트 화면·데이터 처리 이력이며, 이 네 갈래 후보를 사람이 확인한 기록으로 계산하지 않습니다." }, "provenance": { "source_manifest": "/atlas/data/public/source-manifest.json", "detail_locator": "/atlas/data/public/detail-locator.json.gz", "issue_register": "/data-quality-issues.json", "evidence_gap_map": "/evidence-gap-map.json", "correction_policy": "/correction-policy.json", "correction_history": "/atlas/data/public/correction-history.json", "relation_index": "/atlas/data/public/universe-relations.json.gz", "input_files": 104, "input_digest_sha256": "98413621bca9c6025b251fc21444e928d476dd590ae77687d6ba4586fad027b1" } }